I received two comments on yesterday's Saturday Oil Report which deserve a response. Both comments pertained to the tax breaks the oil industry receives. For as long as I can remember, Democrats—liberals, those on the left, progressives—have complained about the massive profits the majors (e.g. ExxonMobil, Chevron, etc.) accrue when oil prices are high. There's little doubt that high oil prices constitute a gift to these producers. Bloomberg reported on the lastest failed attempt to repeal the tax breaks.
The U.S. oil and gas industry survived an effort to repeal $21 billion in tax breaks over 10 years as three Democrats broke with Senate leaders who said the revenue should go to reduce the federal deficit...
Democrats said the oil companies can afford to give up the tax benefits after their combined first-quarter profits exceeded $30 billion. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said he would work to revive the measure in budget talks with Republicans, who are trying to cut more than $6 trillion in spending.
“Instead of defending oil companies, Republicans should be defending the American taxpayer,” Reid of Nevada said before the vote.
The Republicans—conservatives, those on the right, regressives—always assume there is a relationship between tax breaks and oil production. They had a different idea.
A Republican-backed measure that would increase offshore production and expedite permits faces a vote today in the Senate. The legislation mirrors bills passed by the Republican- led U.S. House this month to speed Interior Department rulings on oil-drilling permits. Without action after 60 days, the application would be deemed approved.
A provision also would require lease sales in the Gulf of Mexico and off the coasts of Virginia and Alaska.
OK, let's get back to basics. What is the relationship between either of these proposals, and domestic oil production over the next 10 years? There is no relationship. None. Zero, zip, nada. What is the relationship between either of these proposals and current high oil prices, or future high oil prices? There is no relationship. None. Zero, zip, nada.
Taking $2.1 billion a year from the oil industry over the next 10 years will certainly not raise our oil production, nor will it decrease it. And in the grand scheme of things, $21 billion (21,000,000,000) amounts to nothing, it's pocket change for a government that runs annual deficits in the $1.5 trillion range (1,500,000,000,000).
Opening up additional offshore areas for drilling, even if some operators strike commercial oil, will not put any additional oil on the market until 2021, at least according to every EIA report I've ever read. See my posts Talking About Oil — Complaceny, Panic And Ignorance, and Where Is U.S Oil Production Going?
Imposing heavier taxes on the oil industry is a distraction, a sideshow in the Big Energy War we are losing. In the 6 years I've been analyzing and commenting on the oil markets, the "debate" between Democrats and Republicans has not changed one iota. Our politics is a circus, a sorry spectacle. It is not an energy policy. Consider this nonsense—
Senator Claire McCaskill, a Missouri Democrat, said oil companies shouldn’t get tax breaks given their profits and the size of the federal deficit.
“Maybe we shouldn’t pick on big oil, but what a great place to start,” she said during debate...
The Senate was “right to reject this bill,” which would hurt consumers, said Bruce Josten, executive vice president for government affairs at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the nation’s largest business lobby.
Yes, it's a great place to start if you want to score political points, but it's wholly irrelevant to the inexorable economic forces destroying our standards of living, including future oil scarcity. The bill is wholly irrelevant to the ultimate fate of American "consumers".
Caveat emptor—partisan politics makes you stupid. You can start thinking outside the box, or you can continue to live inside the illusion created by our politicians, our media and the corporate special interests who own them. The choice is yours.